Dining in Surf City, New Jersey: The Real History, and What We Won't Invent
Surf City is a small borough — 1.32 square miles total, with a 2020 census population of 1,243 — sitting on Long Beach Island immediately north of Ship Bottom. Its commercial life runs along a single spine: Long Beach Boulevard, whose roughly one-mile commercial strip holds a mix of small businesses, including mini-golf and food vendors selling the kinds of things a summer beach crowd expects — pizza, ice cream, tacos, smoothies. This page will not invent specific restaurant names, menus, or price points beyond what has been independently confirmed, because doing so would do a visitor more harm than good. What it will do is lay out two real, sourced anchors: the borough's oldest running retail landmark, the Surf City 5&10, and the town's single most storied dining-and-drinking establishment, the Surf City Hotel, whose cocktail lounge and bar history stretches back to the late 1940s. For actual current restaurant names, hours, and menus, check a current Long Beach Island visitor guide or review site before making plans.
Long Beach Boulevard: A One-Mile Strip, Not a Restaurant Row
Surf City has no Interstate, US, or state highway running through it — the only road serving the borough directly is County Route 607, known locally as Long Beach Boulevard. Along roughly one mile of that boulevard sits the borough's entire commercial district: a small-town strip built for a beach crowd rather than a dining destination in its own right. The mix includes mini-golf and food vendors offering pizza, ice cream, tacos, and smoothies — the kind of casual, walk-up, summer-facing food service typical of a small LBI town, rather than a scene organized around sit-down restaurants with published menus.
We did not find confirmed, current names, addresses, or ownership details for any specific pizza shop, ice cream stand, taco counter, or smoothie vendor operating on the strip today, so none are listed here. What is confirmed is the shape of the strip itself: about a mile long, anchored by Long Beach Boulevard, with a handful of small businesses that have historically served both day-trippers and the borough's much larger summer population. Two closely-spaced water towers are a recognizable visual landmark along this same stretch, useful for orienting yourself if you are walking the strip in person.
The Surf City 5&10: Close to Seventy Years on the Boulevard
The single longest-running named business confirmed on Long Beach Boulevard is the Surf City 5&10 — a five-and-dime variety shop, not a restaurant, that per one source has been in business for close to 70 years. It is worth being precise about what the Surf City 5&10 actually is: a longtime local retail shop selling the kind of general merchandise a five-and-dime traditionally carries, not a place to get a meal. Its longevity matters to any honest picture of Surf City's commercial strip, though, because it signals just how long some businesses along this stretch have operated continuously through generations of summer visitors, even as specific food vendors around it have likely changed hands and names many times over the decades.
We have not confirmed an exact founding year for the Surf City 5&10, only the close-to-70-years figure reported in one source, so we present it as an approximate, sourced figure rather than a precise date. No other specific current shop or restaurant names beyond this one and the Surf City Hotel (below) were confirmed in this research pass.
The Surf City Hotel: The Borough’s Most Storied Bar and Dining Landmark
If any single address in Surf City has a real, documented dining-and-drinking history, it is the Surf City Hotel, one of the oldest structures on Long Beach Island. The building operated under several earlier names — Mansion House, Long Beach Inn, and Marquette Hotel — before taking the "Surf City Hotel" name in the early 20th century, and it was originally popular with local fishermen and hunters rather than beach tourists. In the pre-Prohibition era, the venue built a reputation for parties and notoriety, and an earlier version of the building on the same site was rumored to be haunted before it burned down, a story that still circulates locally today. We are not naming a specific ghost or a specific haunted event here, because none was independently confirmed beyond that general characterization.
The hotel's dining-and-bar identity as it is known today took real shape in the late 1940s, when the cocktail lounge was expanded specifically to accommodate the growing wave of summer vacationers coming to Long Beach Island. A Wurlitzer organ was installed in the bar in the late 1950s, and long-time owner Hank Crane later donated that organ to Richmond, Virginia — a small but genuinely documented piece of the hotel's history. Today the Surf City Hotel is owned by Colleen and Greg Gewirtz, who purchased it in April 2017 and have run it since. That ownership detail is current as of this research pass, but readers planning a visit should still check the hotel's own current hours, menu, and offerings directly, since ownership dates do not guarantee unchanged operations years later.
What We Did Not Find, and Will Not Invent
Beyond the Surf City Hotel and the Surf City 5&10 (which, again, is a retail shop, not a restaurant), we did not find confirmed, current (2025/2026) names, cuisines, menus, price ranges, or hours of operation for any other specific restaurant, pizza shop, ice cream stand, taco counter, or smoothie vendor on the Long Beach Boulevard strip. Inventing a plausible-sounding seafood shack or a named ice cream parlor would be easy to do and worse than useless to someone actually trying to plan a meal in Surf City. This research pass also did not turn up a confirmed exact founding date for the Surf City 5&10 beyond the approximate close-to-70-years figure, nor any confirmed current menu or pricing for the Surf City Hotel itself.
What is confirmed, and what this page has focused on instead, is the real structural context: a roughly one-mile commercial strip along Long Beach Boulevard as the borough's only real dining-and-shopping corridor, a long-running five-and-dime landmark in the Surf City 5&10, and a genuinely storied hotel bar and dining history at the Surf City Hotel stretching from its pre-Prohibition notoriety through its late-1940s cocktail-lounge expansion, its late-1950s Wurlitzer organ, and its current ownership since April 2017. For actual restaurant names, current hours, and menus anywhere on the strip, check a current Long Beach Island visitor guide, the Surf City Hotel's own current listings, or an up-to-date review site before making dinner plans. Nothing on this page is a dining recommendation.
Ready to talk to a local Surf City, LBI agent?
Get a Free Agent Referral →Independent research. No ads. No sponsored listings. Data drawn from research on Surf City, New Jersey, a 1.32-square-mile borough on Long Beach Island (2020 census population 1,243) served by a single commercial corridor along County Route 607, known locally as Long Beach Boulevard, whose roughly one-mile stretch includes mini-golf, the Surf City 5&10 (a five-and-dime shop in business for close to 70 years, per one source), and various food vendors offering pizza, ice cream, tacos, and smoothies. Also drawn from documented history of the Surf City Hotel, one of the oldest structures on Long Beach Island, previously known as Mansion House, Long Beach Inn, and Marquette Hotel; popular historically with local fishermen and hunters; known for parties and notoriety in the pre-Prohibition era; tied to local ghost stories about an earlier, rumored-haunted building on the same site that burned down; expanded its cocktail lounge in the late 1940s to serve summer vacationers; installed a Wurlitzer organ in its bar in the late 1950s, later donated by long-time owner Hank Crane to Richmond, Virginia; and has been owned by Colleen and Greg Gewirtz since April 2017. No confirmed current (2025/2026) restaurant names, cuisines, menus, hours, or price points beyond the Surf City Hotel and the Surf City 5&10 (a retail shop, not a restaurant) were found during this research pass, and none are invented here; check a current Long Beach Island visitor guide or review site for that information. Nothing on this page is a dining recommendation.