Hurricane and Storm Risk in Seaside Heights, New Jersey
Seaside Heights is a 0.74-square-mile borough (0.62 square miles of land, 0.13 square miles of water) sitting on the Barnegat Peninsula, a barrier peninsula that separates Barnegat Bay from the open Atlantic Ocean and is reached via NJ Route 37 and the Toms River. That geography is the entire reason storm risk here is a real, structural fact rather than a marketing footnote: a narrow strip of land with open ocean on one side and a tidal bay on the other floods from both directions in a major storm. This page does not state a Seaside-Heights-specific damage percentage for Hurricane Sandy, because none was confirmed during research, and it does not borrow a damage figure from Long Beach Island's Ship Bottom, Surf City, Harvey Cedars, or Barnegat Light, because those are a different barrier peninsula entirely, reached by a different route, with their own separately reported numbers. What is confirmed, and what makes this town's storm history genuinely distinct from every other market on this site, is what happened to a single roller coaster on Casino Pier in October 2012.
This Site's Nineteenth New Jersey Market, and a Barrier Peninsula by Design
Seaside Heights is this site's nineteenth New Jersey market. Its physical footprint explains its storm exposure directly: 0.74 total square miles, split between 0.62 square miles of land and 0.13 square miles of water, on the Barnegat Peninsula, a barrier landform between Barnegat Bay to the west and the Atlantic Ocean to the east. A barrier peninsula of that width does not have the option of retreating from either shoreline; a storm surge from the ocean side and a bay-driven flood from the west can arrive from opposite directions in the same event.
That is a different geography from Long Beach Island to the south, and this page is deliberately built to not reuse any LBI market's storm-damage percentage as if it were Seaside Heights' own. Ship Bottom, Surf City, Harvey Cedars, and Barnegat Light sit on a separate barrier island, reached over the Route 72 causeway, with their own independently reported Sandy damage figures. Seaside Heights is reached from the mainland via Route 37 and the Toms River, and its own storm history, most visibly on Casino Pier, is documented on its own terms below rather than borrowed from a neighboring market.
Hurricane Sandy, October 29, 2012: The Boardwalk and Both Piers
Hurricane Sandy made its impact on Seaside Heights beginning October 29, 2012. Substantial portions of the borough's boardwalk were damaged, and much of the borough itself flooded. Both of the town's amusement piers, Casino Pier and Funtown Pier, each extending roughly 300 feet into the Atlantic as part of the roughly two-mile boardwalk running along the town, sustained major damage, with amusement rides collapsing during the storm.
No confirmed, Seaside-Heights-specific percentage of buildings damaged or destroyed by Sandy was found during research for this page, and none is invented here. What is confirmed is the general severity described above: widespread borough flooding, extensive boardwalk damage, and structural failure of amusement rides on both piers. A prospective owner should treat that as the honest baseline of what a major Atlantic hurricane can do to this specific stretch of the Barnegat Peninsula, and should get a current flood-zone determination from FEMA's Flood Map Service Center rather than rely on any single storm's damage description as a predictor of the next one.
The Star Jet: How One Fallen Coaster Became Sandy’s Global Symbol
The single most consequential storm-risk fact about Seaside Heights is what happened to the Star Jet, a roller coaster on Casino Pier. During Hurricane Sandy, the Star Jet fell into the Atlantic Ocean. Partially submerged in the surf, it became a widely photographed, internationally recognized symbol of Hurricane Sandy's destruction, appearing in news coverage around the world as shorthand for the storm's power.
The wrecked coaster did not come down immediately. It remained standing partially in the ocean for months afterward, becoming a genuine tourist curiosity, drawing visitors who came specifically to see it, before it was finally demolished on May 14, 2013. That roughly six-and-a-half-month window between storm and demolition is part of why the image had time to become as recognizable as it did: it was not a single photograph but a lingering, visitable landmark of the disaster.
What Replaced It: Two Reported Coasters, No Single Confirmed Current Lineup
Casino Pier was rebuilt after Sandy, and a new coaster was later constructed to replace the Star Jet. Reporting from WGBH/NPR in 2017 describes a replacement coaster opening that year. More recent reporting, from CBS New York, references a further, newer coaster called Hydrus at the same pier. This page presents both facts as they were reported rather than asserting a single, current-as-of-2026 ride lineup for Casino Pier, since amusement offerings change from season to season and no independently confirmed, up-to-date ride list was found during research.
For a prospective buyer, the practical takeaway is not which specific coaster operates today. It is that Casino Pier itself has now been rebuilt more than once since 2012, which says something concrete about both the town's rebuilding capacity after a direct hurricane hit and the ongoing capital cost of maintaining an amusement pier exposed to the open Atlantic. Confirm Casino Pier's current ride lineup directly with the pier's own operator before planning a visit around any specific attraction.
Not Seaside Park’s Fire, and Not Seaside Park’s 2016 Story
Seaside Heights should not be confused with its immediate neighbor, Seaside Park, built in this same research batch. Seaside Park's own spine belongs to a separate, later disaster: a September 12, 2013 ten-alarm boardwalk fire that Wikipedia documents primarily under "2013 Seaside Park, New Jersey fire," since it damaged the Seaside Park end of the shared boardwalk in detail, and a 2016 boardwalk bombing that is Seaside Park's own story, not Seaside Heights'. That 2013 fire did also sweep into Seaside Heights' Funtown Pier, destroying businesses including Jack & Bill's Bar and Kohr's Custard, both of which had also burned decades earlier in Seaside Heights' 1955 "Freeman's Fire." But no exact building count or dollar-damage figure specific to Seaside Heights' own portion of that 2013 fire was found, and none is invented here; the detailed cause, origin building, and firebreak-demolition figures belong properly to Seaside Park's own page.
The distinction matters for storm-risk purposes specifically: Seaside Heights' own defining disaster-recovery story is Hurricane Sandy and the Star Jet, a weather event, while Seaside Park's defining disaster stories are a fire and a bombing, neither of which is a storm. A buyer researching either town should keep the two straight rather than assume one town's disaster history applies to the other.
Adding It Up: A Real, Photographed Storm History, and What We Will Not Invent
What is confirmed here: Seaside Heights sits on a 0.74-square-mile barrier peninsula between Barnegat Bay and the Atlantic Ocean; Hurricane Sandy struck beginning October 29, 2012, flooding much of the borough and heavily damaging the boardwalk and both Casino Pier and Funtown Pier; the Star Jet roller coaster fell into the ocean during the storm, became a globally recognized symbol of Sandy's destruction, remained a visitable tourist curiosity for roughly seven months, and was demolished May 14, 2013; and Casino Pier has since been rebuilt with a reported 2017 replacement coaster and, per more recent reporting, a newer Hydrus coaster, without a single confirmed current-year ride list.
What we could not find, and will not invent: a Seaside-Heights-specific percentage of homes or buildings damaged or destroyed by Sandy, a current flood-insurance premium, a current FEMA flood-zone designation for any specific address, and a confirmed, single current ride lineup for Casino Pier. Get a current flood-zone determination from FEMA's Flood Map Service Center, a current flood and wind insurance quote from a licensed New Jersey agent, and current storm-mitigation requirements from the Borough of Seaside Heights before making any purchase decision. Nothing on this page is legal, tax, insurance, or financial advice.
Ready to talk to a local Seaside Heights agent?
Get a Free Agent Referral →Independent research. No ads. No sponsored listings. Data drawn from research on Seaside Heights, New Jersey, including its location on the Barnegat Peninsula, a barrier peninsula separating Barnegat Bay from the Atlantic Ocean, reached via NJ Route 37 and the Toms River; a total area of 0.74 square miles (0.62 square miles land, 0.13 square miles water); Hurricane Sandy's impact beginning October 29, 2012, which damaged substantial portions of the boardwalk, flooded much of the borough, and caused major damage with collapsing rides at both Casino Pier and Funtown Pier, each extending roughly 300 feet into the Atlantic along the town's roughly two-mile boardwalk; the Star Jet roller coaster on Casino Pier, which fell into the Atlantic Ocean during the storm, became a widely photographed, internationally recognized symbol of Hurricane Sandy's destruction, remained a tourist curiosity before being demolished May 14, 2013; a replacement coaster reported by WGBH/NPR (2017) as opening that year at Casino Pier, with more recent CBS New York reporting also referencing a newer "Hydrus" coaster at the same pier, presented without asserting a single confirmed current ride lineup; the September 12, 2013 ten-alarm fire that swept Funtown Pier, destroying businesses including Jack & Bill's Bar and Kohr's Custard (both of which had also burned in the 1955 "Freeman's Fire"), documented by Wikipedia primarily under "2013 Seaside Park, New Jersey fire" as damaging the Seaside Park end of the shared boardwalk, with no Seaside-Heights-specific building or dollar-damage figure confirmed; and the June 9, 1955 "Freeman's Fire," in which a malfunctioning neon sign sparked a blaze destroying 85 buildings with an estimated $4 million in damage. Seaside Heights is this site's nineteenth New Jersey market, and its Hurricane Sandy and Star Jet history is treated as its own, distinct from Long Beach Island's Ship Bottom, Surf City, Harvey Cedars, and Barnegat Light (a separate barrier island with its own independently reported storm-damage figures) and from neighboring Seaside Park (whose own 2013 fire detail and 2016 boardwalk bombing are that town's separate story). A Seaside-Heights-specific Sandy damage percentage, a current flood-insurance premium, a current FEMA flood-zone designation for any specific address, and a confirmed single current Casino Pier ride lineup were not independently confirmed this research pass and are disclosed as gaps rather than invented. Confirm current flood-zone status with FEMA's Flood Map Service Center, current insurance costs with a licensed New Jersey agent, and current storm-mitigation rules with the Borough of Seaside Heights before making any purchase decision. Nothing on this page is legal, tax, insurance, or financial advice.