Scarborough Vacation Rental Investment
This page is about Scarborough, Maine — a Cumberland County town on Route 1/I-95 roughly seven miles south of Portland, home to Higgins Beach, Pine Point, and Prouts Neck. It is not the Scarborough neighborhood of Narragansett, Rhode Island covered elsewhere on this site, and it has nothing to do with Scarborough in North Yorkshire, England, Ontario, Canada, or Westchester County, New York — four unrelated places share this name, and this page concerns only the Maine town, sometimes referred to here as Scarborough/Higgins Beach for clarity. For an investor, Scarborough is genuinely the higher-end market within this site's Maine coverage: its typical home value and its median sale price both run well above Wells and Old Orchard Beach. It is also, honestly, the market in this cluster with the thinnest confirmed rental-specific data — this page discloses those gaps directly rather than filling them with invented numbers, including a genuine unresolved question about the town's current short-term-rental rules that should not be assumed to mirror any neighboring town's ordinance.
A Genuinely Higher-End Entry Price Than Wells or Old Orchard Beach
Zillow's Home Value Index puts Scarborough's typical home value at $705,594, current through data reported June 30, 2026 — down 1.1% over the past year, with homes reportedly going to pending in around eight days, which points to a market still moving briskly even as the typical value ticked down slightly. Redfin-style data (via Movoto, which cites MLS figures similar to Redfin's own city page) puts Scarborough's median sale price at $799,000 as of June 2026, with 110 homes sold that month versus 93 in the same month a year earlier, and average days on market down to 30 from 33 the prior year — a market turning over faster and with rising sales volume even as the typical-value figure softened slightly.
The U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey puts Scarborough's median value of owner-occupied housing units at $551,900 (2020-2024, five-year estimate). That figure is a trailing, blended baseline by design and should be read as historical context, not a current-market number — the Zillow and Redfin/Movoto figures above are the more current reference points. Set against this site's other Maine coverage, Scarborough is a genuinely pricier market: it is not being positioned here as an entry-level Maine beach-town purchase, but as the higher-end option in this site's Maine cluster.
What This Research Could Not Confirm: Neighborhood-Level Prices and Any Scarborough-Specific Rental Numbers
Every price figure above is townwide. This research did not locate a Zillow, Redfin, or Movoto figure specific to Higgins Beach or Prouts Neck as distinct micro-markets — only the blended Scarborough total, which includes large inland and suburban sections of town (Oak Hill, North Scarborough, Dunstan, and others) that are not beach property at all. Higgins Beach and Prouts Neck, as tightly bounded, highly desirable waterfront areas, plausibly carry meaningfully higher price points than the townwide figures above, but this page will not guess at a specific number for either one. A Zillow page dedicated to Prouts Neck exists but could not be pulled during this research; an investor evaluating a specific Higgins Beach or Prouts Neck property should pull that neighborhood-level data directly rather than applying the townwide figures to a waterfront parcel.
More importantly for underwriting an actual purchase: this research found no confirmed average nightly rate, no confirmed occupancy rate, and no confirmed cap rate specific to short-term rentals in Scarborough. That is a genuine, disclosed gap, not an oversight, and it is a meaningfully thinner rental data set than this site has been able to document for some other Maine markets. Before underwriting a Scarborough property around any assumed rental income, get current nightly-rate and occupancy comparables from a licensed Maine property manager active in this specific market, and have the property itself appraised by a licensed Maine appraiser rather than relying on townwide home-value figures as a stand-in for unit-level rental economics.
The Question This Page Cannot Answer: Scarborough's Current Short-Term-Rental Rules
This is worth stating plainly because it is easy to get wrong by analogy. Old Orchard Beach, covered elsewhere on this site, has a well-documented, current story: its Town Council unanimously rejected a proposed short-term-rental moratorium in October 2023, and roughly 800 active short-term rentals operate there today with no cap. That story belongs to Old Orchard Beach alone. This research found no equivalent confirmation, one way or the other, of Scarborough's current short-term-rental ordinance or regulatory framework — no confirmed cap, no confirmed licensing requirement, no confirmed absence of restrictions, and no confirmed recent Town Council action on the subject either way.
That is a genuine gap in this research, not a signal that Scarborough is unregulated or that it mirrors Old Orchard Beach's framework. Before assuming any particular short-term-rental rule applies to a Scarborough property, a prospective investor should verify current rules directly with the Town of Scarborough's planning and code enforcement office (scarboroughmaine.org) — including whether a permit or registration is required, whether any cap or waitlist exists, and whether rules differ between Higgins Beach, Pine Point, and Prouts Neck specifically, given how differently those three areas are governed on the ground (see below).
One of the Lower Coastal Mil Rates Near Portland — But Maine Still Taxes Income
Scarborough's FY2025-2026 mil rate is $11.33 per $1,000 of assessed valuation, effective August 20, 2025. A comparison table sourced alongside that figure shows Scarborough running below several coastal and greater-Portland neighbors — South Portland at $13.20, Saco at $14.05, Westbrook at $14.75, Portland itself at $15.01 — and roughly in line with Cape Elizabeth. For a carrying-cost calculation, that is a genuinely favorable position: Scarborough is one of the lower property-tax rates among coastal and greater-Portland towns, without being the cheapest waterfront real estate in the group.
That mil rate is only one side of the ledger. Maine levies a state personal income tax, and rental income from a Scarborough property is taxed on top of whatever the mil-rate comparison shows. This page does not model that after-tax impact, because it depends entirely on an owner's full income and filing situation — that calculation belongs with a Maine-licensed tax professional working from the specific numbers of the property and the owner, not a generic multiplication of a mil rate against a purchase price.
Higgins Beach and Pine Point Are Not the Same Renter Market
Scarborough's coastline is not one uniform rental product, and the difference matters for who a given property will attract. Higgins Beach is a small, specific, named oceanfront village with a genuinely programmed community calendar — the Higgins Beach Association runs a summer concert series, craft shows, a July 4th celebration, and weekly summer beach yoga. A property there sits inside a small-village identity with real, recurring events, not a resort-chain amenity list. Pine Point, at Scarborough's southern end, has a quieter, more residential and working-village character built around commercial fishing — the Pine Point Fisherman's Co-Op and a commercial pier completed in 2011 anchor its identity.
One geographic fact is worth stating directly because it is the single easiest thing to get wrong about this market: Pine Point Beach is physically the same continuous sand strand as Old Orchard Beach, divided only by a town line, not by any natural break. But Pine Point does not carry Old Orchard Beach's boardwalk, pier, and arcade character — that identity belongs entirely to Old Orchard Beach. A renter drawn to OOB's amusement-park scene is looking for something meaningfully different from what Pine Point offers, and a Scarborough property should be marketed and priced against Pine Point's own quieter, residential character rather than borrowed boardwalk-town appeal.
Prouts Neck: A Fundamentally Different, More Restricted Market
Prouts Neck deserves separate treatment because it is not a typical open coastal neighborhood. It is a largely built-out, seasonal summer colony with private, gated roads and its own police patrol. The Prouts Neck Country Club, established in 1907, operates an 18-hole golf course and tennis restricted to residents, and the Prouts Neck Yacht Club runs youth sailing and racing for the same private membership. This is a genuinely more exclusive, more restricted-access area than Higgins Beach or Pine Point, and that has direct investment implications.
A prospective investor should not assume a Prouts Neck property can be freely rented short-term the way an open-market coastal property might be. Private-road agreements, a residents-only country club, and the area's small, association-governed character all suggest that private covenants or neighborhood norms could significantly limit short-term-rental feasibility there, separate from whatever the town's own ordinance says. This research did not find a specific Prouts Neck rental-restriction document, so this is disclosed as a genuine consideration to investigate directly — through the relevant property association and a title search — rather than a confirmed rule.
The Downs: A Large Nearby Growth Driver, Not a Beachfront Opportunity Itself
Separate from the coastline, Scarborough is home to one of the more significant active redevelopment stories on the Maine coast: a shuttered, 70-year horse-racing track (Scarborough Downs, which held its final live races in late November 2020) is being rebuilt from scratch into "The Downs," a 525-acre, master-planned mixed-use town center led by M&R Holdings. At full build-out, the project is projected at roughly $615 million in new assessed value, about $10 million in annual tax revenue, and up to 3,000 new jobs across roughly 2 million square feet of commercial space. The site already includes Maine's first Costco and Idexx offices, with a Market Basket announced in November 2024 and Allagash Brewing committed to a planned location around a central green.
This is genuinely relevant context for a Scarborough investor because a project of this scale can affect broader housing demand, employment, and local retail and dining options town-wide. It is inland and non-beachfront, however, and this page does not present it as a beachfront investment opportunity in itself — it belongs in the picture as a driver of overall town growth and demand, not as a coastal rental play.
Coastal Risk: A 2025 Vulnerability Assessment and a Real Constraint on Hard Infrastructure
Scarborough took real, documented storm damage in a January 2024 storm surge, with the worst effects concentrated at Higgins Beach — rocks driven through windows by wave action at homes closest to the water, sections of the beachfront road broken up, and at least one home with significant basement flooding. In response, the town commissioned a formal coastal vulnerability assessment, with recommendations presented in September 2025. Per WGME's reporting on that assessment, 38 roads in Scarborough currently face coastal flooding risk, a number projected to rise to 100 roads within 25 years without intervention. Recommended measures include temporary flood barriers, defined evacuation routes, and elevating Pine Point Road.
A specific regulatory constraint flagged by the town's own sustainability manager is directly relevant to any coastal property here: because Pine Point and Higgins Beach sit within state-mapped sand dune systems, Maine's dune rules sharply limit what hard infrastructure — seawalls, for instance — the town or a property owner can build there. For a long-term coastal investment, that means the usual hard-armoring response to erosion may simply not be available in these specific neighborhoods, which is a real factor to weigh alongside purchase price and rental potential, not a hypothetical one.
Bottom Line: What This Page Does and Does Not Tell You
What is confirmed: Scarborough's typical home value is $705,594 (Zillow, down 1.1% year over year, homes to pending in about eight days), and its median sale price is $799,000 (Redfin-style data via Movoto, June 2026, 110 homes sold versus 93 the prior year, days on market down to 30). Both figures run genuinely higher than Wells and Old Orchard Beach, positioning Scarborough as this site's higher-end Maine market. The FY2025-2026 mil rate is $11.33 per $1,000, one of the lower rates among coastal and greater-Portland towns, though Maine's state income tax still applies to rental income on top of that. Higgins Beach's small, event-driven community character and Pine Point's quieter, working-village character are genuinely different renter profiles despite sharing a physical sand strand with Old Orchard Beach, and Prouts Neck's private, gated, country-club character makes it a fundamentally more restricted sub-market. The Downs, a 525-acre, $615 million inland town-center redevelopment, is a real nearby growth driver, and the town's 2025 coastal vulnerability assessment (38 roads at risk today, rising to 100 within 25 years) plus Maine's dune-rule limits on hard shoreline infrastructure are real long-term risk factors for coastal property here.
What is not confirmed, and what this page does not invent: any neighborhood-specific Zillow or Redfin figure for Higgins Beach or Prouts Neck as distinct from the townwide Scarborough numbers; any current average nightly rate, occupancy rate, or cap rate for a Scarborough short-term rental; and, most importantly, Scarborough's current short-term-rental ordinance or regulatory status, which this research could not confirm one way or the other and which should never be assumed to match Old Orchard Beach's well-documented, unrestricted framework. Nothing on this page is investment, tax, or legal advice. Before buying a Scarborough property with rental income in mind, verify current short-term-rental rules directly with the Town of Scarborough's planning and code enforcement office, and consult a Maine-licensed real estate professional, a Maine-licensed property manager or appraiser for unit-level underwriting, and a Maine-licensed tax professional about the specific property under consideration.
Ready to talk to a local Scarborough / Higgins Beach agent?
Get a Free Agent Referral →Independent research. No ads. No sponsored listings. This page is about Scarborough, Maine, in Cumberland County, home to Higgins Beach, Pine Point, and Prouts Neck — a distinct town from Scarborough, a neighborhood of Narragansett, Rhode Island, already covered elsewhere on this site, and unrelated to Scarborough in North Yorkshire, England; Scarborough, Ontario, Canada; or the Scarborough hamlet in Westchester County, New York. Home-value and sale-price figures are from Zillow's Home Value Index (zillow.com/home-values/395844/scarborough-me/, $705,594, down 1.1% year over year, data through June 30, 2026) and Movoto, citing Redfin-style MLS data (movoto.com/scarborough-me/market-trends/, $799,000 median sale price, June 2026, 110 homes sold versus 93 the prior year, 30-day average days on market versus 33 the prior year). The Census ACS median owner-occupied home value ($551,900, 2020-2024 five-year estimate) is per Census QuickFacts. The FY2025-2026 mil rate ($11.33 per $1,000, effective August 20, 2025) and the comparison figures for neighboring towns are per SEDCO's Scarborough tax page, sourced from the town; this page recommends verifying the current rate directly with the Town of Scarborough's assessing office. The Higgins Beach Association's concert series, craft shows, July 4th celebration, and weekly summer beach yoga are per the HBA's own site and HigginsBeachMaine.com. Pine Point's Fisherman's Co-Op and 2011 commercial pier are per Portland Press Herald reporting. Prouts Neck's private roads, its own police patrol, and the Prouts Neck Country Club (established 1907, residents-only golf and tennis) and Prouts Neck Yacht Club are per Wikipedia's entry on Prouts Neck. The Downs redevelopment details — the 525-acre scope, roughly $615 million in projected new assessed value, up to 3,000 new jobs, Maine's first Costco, the November 2024 Market Basket announcement, and Allagash Brewing's committed location — are per Portland Press Herald and MEREDA reporting on the project. The January 2024 storm damage at Higgins Beach is per Bangor Daily News and Portland Press Herald coverage. The 2025 coastal vulnerability assessment findings (38 roads currently at risk, rising to 100 within 25 years, and the dune-rule constraint on hard infrastructure at Pine Point and Higgins Beach) are per WGME's reporting on the town's coastal resiliency planning. This research did not find, and this page does not invent, any neighborhood-specific Higgins Beach or Prouts Neck home-value figure distinct from the townwide Scarborough numbers, any current Scarborough-specific short-term-rental nightly rate, occupancy rate, or cap rate, or any confirmation of Scarborough's current short-term-rental ordinance status — that last point should not be assumed to match Old Orchard Beach's separately documented, unrestricted short-term-rental framework, which applies only to that town. Nothing here is investment, tax, or legal advice; before buying, verify current short-term-rental rules directly with the Town of Scarborough (scarboroughmaine.org) and consult a Maine-licensed real estate professional, a Maine-licensed property manager or appraiser, and a Maine tax professional about the specific property you are considering.