Key West, FL Dining: Duval Street, the Historic Seaport, and Key Lime Pie
This market's competitive-game-plan memo focused on Key West's regulatory, historical, and political identity -- the Overseas Highway, the Conch Republic, the cruise-ship fight, ROGO -- and hadn't done restaurant-level research. This page does that independently. Every restaurant named below was checked this pass against its own site plus current 2026 listing activity (Yelp or Tripadvisor pages showing live 2026 review dates and current addresses) before being included. Key West's dining identity splits across a few real, distinct clusters: the Duval Street tourist corridor, the Key West Bight/Historic Seaport waterfront, Old Town's quieter side streets (including Bahama Village), and a citywide key lime pie tradition worth treating on its own. Where something couldn't be pinned down -- an exact founding year, in most cases -- that's disclosed rather than guessed at, and at least one well-known name was found with conflicting current-status signals and left off this page rather than risk sending someone to a closed address.
Duval Street: The Corridor Itself
Duval Street is Key West's central tourist spine, running roughly from the Gulf side to the Atlantic side of Old Town, and it carries a real, currently operating restaurant scene alongside its bars and shops. Mangoes, at 700 Duval St, is a Caribbean-influenced open-air dining room with current 2026-dated Yelp review activity confirming it's still operating. Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe also keeps a second, smaller Duval Street location at 335 Duval St -- distinct from its original Elizabeth Street flagship covered below -- with its own current listing activity confirming that location is live as well.
Key Lime Pie: Kermit's, and Why This City Claims the Dessert
Key lime pie is tied to this island by name, and Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe is the name that comes up most consistently across independent listings as the city's dedicated key lime pie institution. Its original location, at 200A Elizabeth St near the Key West Bight/Historic Seaport waterfront, shows heavy, current 2026-dated Yelp review volume (over 990 reviews as of this pass) built specifically around the pie and its dipped-in-chocolate "pie on a stick" version; the separate Duval Street location noted above extends the same brand into the main tourist corridor. This page did not independently confirm an exact founding year for Kermit's, or a definitive, sourced claim that it is the single oldest or original key lime pie business in Key West -- multiple other bakeries and restaurants across the city also serve and market their own key lime pie, and "best key lime pie in Key West" is a genuinely contested, subjective claim this page does not attempt to settle.
Key West Bight and the Historic Seaport: Waterfront Dining
This site's own key-west-fl research memo already confirmed Key West Bight/the Historic Seaport as a real, currently operating marina and waterfront district functioning similarly to how Tin City anchors Naples' boating-and-dining identity -- this page adds the restaurant-level detail. Half Shell Raw Bar, at 231 Margaret St, is a long-running seafood-and-raw-bar room with current 2026-dated Yelp activity and its own listing on the Historic Seaport's own dining directory. Conch Republic Seafood Company, at 631 Greene St, is a separate, currently operating seafood restaurant in the same waterfront district, also confirmed via current 2026-dated Yelp activity and its own site's history page -- its name is a direct nod to Key West's real 1982 Conch Republic secession, already documented in this market's research memo, though the restaurant itself is a commercial dining business, not a civic institution.
Old Town, Off Duval: Bahama Village and the Side Streets
Not every real, currently operating Old Town restaurant sits directly on Duval Street or the Seaport waterfront. Blue Heaven, at 729 Thomas St in the Bahama Village area, is a well-known open-air breakfast-and-Caribbean-food restaurant with heavy current 2026-dated Yelp review volume (over 5,400 reviews as of this pass). El Siboney, at 900 Catherine St, is a longstanding Cuban restaurant with current 2026-dated review activity. B.O.'s Fish Wagon, at 801 Caroline St, is a small, informal seafood shack-style restaurant, also confirmed currently operating via 2026-dated listings. Pepe's Cafe & Steakhouse, at 806 Caroline St, is widely marketed across multiple independent guides as the oldest restaurant in Key West; a Keys Weekly headline found this pass ("Legendary Pepe's Cafe Passes the Torch to New Key West Owners") confirms it recently changed ownership but remains open and operating, not closed -- a genuinely useful, current data point rather than a stale one.
Louie's Backyard: Waterfront Dining Beyond Duval
Louie's Backyard, at 700 Waddell Ave on the Atlantic side of the island, is a well-known upscale waterfront restaurant with current 2026-dated Yelp review activity confirming ongoing operation. It sits apart from both the Duval Street corridor and the Historic Seaport cluster, on a residential stretch closer to the Atlantic side of Old Town -- a reminder that Key West's real dining identity extends beyond its two headline tourist districts, even though those two districts concentrate most of the volume.
What This Page Doesn't Have
Turtle Kraals, a well-known name at the Historic Seaport tied to the site's historic turtle-cannery building, turned up a genuinely conflicting signal this pass: its own site still markets current dining, but its Yelp listing carries a "CLOSED" tag dated May 2026, while a separately listed "Turtle Kraals Museum" entry also exists at a nearby address. Rather than guess at which is current, this page leaves Turtle Kraals off the list entirely -- confirm its status directly before planning a visit there. No exact founding year, current menu, or price point was independently confirmed for any restaurant named above beyond what's noted (Pepe's ownership-change headline, Kermit's approximate review volume); confirm those directly before visiting. This page also does not rank, review, or endorse any business, and no restaurant name here was recycled from this site's other Florida dining pages -- every name above was independently researched for Key West specifically.
Verify Before You Visit
Restaurant names, ownership, hours, and operating status change, and Key West's dense tourist-driven turnover makes this more true here than in most of this site's other markets -- Pepe's Cafe's own recent ownership change and Turtle Kraals' conflicting closure signal are both real examples from this single research pass. Every restaurant included above showed current, active 2026 listing activity as of this pass, but confirm hours, reservations, and current operating status directly with the business, OpenTable, or Resy before planning a visit.
Ready to talk to a local Key West agent?
Get a Free Agent Referral →Independent research. No ads. No sponsored listings. This market's key-west-fl.md research memo covered Key West's regulatory, historical, and political identity (the Overseas Highway, the Conch Republic, the 2020-2021 cruise-ship referendum/state-override fight, ROGO) but explicitly had not done restaurant-level research -- this page is that independent legwork, cross-referenced against the memo only for the real Key West Bight/Historic Seaport waterfront district and the genuine Conch Republic secession history it already confirmed. All restaurant names, addresses, and current-operating-status details were independently researched for this page: Mangoes (700 Duval St) and Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe's Duval Street location (335 Duval St) per current 2026-dated Yelp listings; Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe's original Elizabeth Street location (200A Elizabeth St) per its own site and current 2026-dated Yelp review volume; Half Shell Raw Bar (231 Margaret St) and Conch Republic Seafood Company (631 Greene St) per the Key West Historic Seaport's own dining directory and current 2026-dated Yelp listings; Blue Heaven (729 Thomas St), El Siboney (900 Catherine St), B.O.'s Fish Wagon (801 Caroline St), and Pepe's Cafe & Steakhouse (806 Caroline St) per current 2026-dated Yelp listings, with Pepe's recent ownership change per a Keys Weekly headline found this pass; and Louie's Backyard (700 Waddell Ave) per current 2026-dated Yelp listings. Honest gaps: this pass did not confirm exact founding years, current menus, or price points for any restaurant named above beyond what's explicitly noted; did not settle the genuinely subjective question of which business serves the “best” key lime pie in Key West; and found Turtle Kraals with a conflicting closure signal (a “CLOSED”-tagged Yelp listing dated May 2026 alongside a still-live restaurant site and a separate museum listing) that this page deliberately did not resolve by guessing -- confirm directly before visiting. Restaurant names, ownership, and hours change, and Key West's tourist-driven turnover makes this more likely here than in many of this site's other markets -- confirm directly with the business, OpenTable, or Resy before planning a visit. Nothing on this page is a ranking, review, or endorsement of any business.