What Nobody Tells You About East Hampton and Amagansett
"East Hampton" on a listing or a map covers two genuinely different places sharing one name and one destination page here: East Hampton Village, laid out by Puritan settlers in 1648 around a wide common, and the hamlet of Amagansett, settled in 1680 and home to the deliberately quiet Devon Colony. Marketing copy tends to blur the two into a single "wealthy Hamptons town" story. This page does not. It walks through what the discretion built into Amagansett's oldest money actually means for a buyer trying to find real pricing data, what the village's own population figures look like when read carefully rather than skimmed, who actually lives in East Hampton Village day to day, and why treating this as one place instead of two can lead a buyer astray. None of this is a reason to avoid either place. It is the context that belongs on the table before a decision gets made.
One Name, Two Places, Two Founding Stories
East Hampton Village and Amagansett are frequently treated as interchangeable because they share a destination page, a school district reputation, and a general sense of Hamptons wealth. Their actual histories are not interchangeable. East Hampton Village was established in 1648, when Puritan settlers laid out home lots of 8 to 12 acres around a wide common -- today's Main Street area -- on the plain north of Hook Pond, dividing the surrounding farmland into the Eastern Plain, Great Plain, and Little Plain. Hook Mill, Gardiner Windmill, and the Home Sweet Home house still stand from that era. In the final quarter of the 1800s, artists discovered the area's agrarian landscape, and a summer colony grew up around it: modest shingled cottages near Ocean Avenue and Lily Pond Lane on the Great Plain, and sizable estates on the Eastern Plain by the early 1900s.
Amagansett was settled in 1680 -- three decades later -- by families including the Bakers, Conklins, and Barneses, along with Dutch brothers Abraham and Jacob Schellinger, who arrived between 1680 and 1690. Its name comes from a Montaukett-language phrase meaning "place of good water." In the late 19th century, Procter & Gamble executives established the Devon Colony there, an enclave built around generational, understated wealth rather than public display -- a different flavor of money than the artist-colony-turned-estate identity next door in the village. Treating "East Hampton" as a single, uniform market skips over the fact that a buyer is really choosing between two places with different founding dates, different early residents, and different cultures around money.
The Devon Colony Is Discreet on Purpose -- Which Means Thin Data for You
Devon Colony's defining trait is not just wealth; it is discretion. The enclave was built by Procter & Gamble executives around a generational, low-profile approach to money rather than a public one, and its properties reportedly rarely enter the public real estate market and maintain real price discretion when they do change hands. For a buyer, that has a practical consequence that no brochure will spell out: if you are trying to research comparable sales, typical price ranges, or turnover patterns in or near this enclave the way you would for an ordinary listing, you should expect the public record to be thinner and less current than it would be in a more conventional market.
This page does not have -- and will not invent -- a current Devon Colony property count, a specific price figure, or a named family beyond the general description of "Procter & Gamble executives" who founded it. No exact current 2026 home price, property-tax rate, or flood-insurance figure specific to East Hampton Village or Amagansett is available in the research behind this page either, and none is presented here as fact. Anyone seriously evaluating a purchase near this kind of discretion-first enclave should treat publicly available pricing data as incomplete by design, not as a market failure, and should confirm actual comparables, tax figures, and insurance costs directly with a local real estate agent, town records, and a licensed insurance professional before making assumptions.
The Village's Growth Numbers Look Wild -- Read Them Carefully
A third-party population estimate puts East Hampton Village's 2024 population at 1,297 and projects 1,553 by 2026, and the same source reports a 49.3% population change between 2019 and 2024 -- an annual rate of change of 9.9%. Read at face value, those numbers suggest a small village growing explosively in just a few years. Before repeating that figure as fact, it is worth being explicit about what it is: a third-party estimate, not a confirmed U.S. Census Bureau figure at the village level for these specific years. Small-population places are also simply more volatile on a percentage basis -- a modest change in raw headcount at a base of roughly 1,300 people produces a large-looking percentage swing that would barely register in a bigger town.
The confirmed Census numbers sit one level up, at the Town of East Hampton (which encompasses both East Hampton Village and Amagansett hamlet, among other areas): 2020 census population 28,385, 2010 census population 21,457, and a July 2025 estimate of 29,400, up 3.7% from April 2020, with a town-wide population density of 381.9 people per square mile as of 2020. Those town-level figures show real but modest growth, nothing close to the village-level estimate's 49.3% swing. A buyer who encounters the village-level number should treat it as a directional estimate worth asking a local source to confirm, not as a settled Census fact.
An Older, More Settled Village Than the Postcard Suggests
East Hampton Village's 2024 estimated median age is 57.5 years -- notably older than what "beach town" marketing typically implies, and a meaningfully more settled, retirement- and second-home-skewed population than a place built around young families or a summertime rental crowd. The same estimate puts median household income at $106,250, a poverty rate of 3.4% of families, and a racial and ethnic makeup of 68.5% White, 25.8% Hispanic, and 2.6% two or more races.
None of that is a reason for or against buying here. It is a demographic reality check: a village with a median age near 58 has a different day-to-day rhythm, a different mix of year-round services, and a different sense of who your neighbors will actually be than a beach town built around a younger, more transient population. Anyone picturing East Hampton Village life primarily through the lens of summer social scenes should weigh that against what the resident population actually looks like most of the year.
What the Facts Add Up to for a Buyer
Put together: "East Hampton" as a destination is really two places sharing a page -- a village founded in 1648 around an artist-colony-turned-estate identity, and an Amagansett hamlet founded in 1680 whose Devon Colony was built deliberately around discretion rather than display, which means thinner public pricing data near that enclave than a typical listing search would turn up. The village's own population figures include a striking 49.3% five-year change and a 2026 projection of 1,553 from a third-party estimate that is not a confirmed Census figure, sitting alongside a more modest, Census-confirmed town-wide picture of 21,457 (2010), 28,385 (2020), and roughly 29,400 (July 2025). And the village's median age of 57.5 years describes a settled, older resident population, not the young beach-town crowd the marketing often implies.
None of this is a verdict for or against buying in East Hampton Village or Amagansett -- it is the set of facts that belongs on the table before the name recognition and the summer social calendar make the decision instead. No confirmed current 2026 home price, property-tax rate, or flood-insurance figure for either place is presented here; treat any such number encountered elsewhere as unverified and confirm current figures directly with a local real estate agent, Town of East Hampton records, and a licensed insurance agent before making an offer. Nothing here is legal, tax, or financial advice.
Ready to talk to a local East Hampton / Amagansett agent?
Get a Free Agent Referral →Independent research. No ads. No sponsored listings. Data drawn from research on East Hampton Village and Amagansett, New York, including: East Hampton Village's establishment in 1648, when Puritan settlers laid out home lots of 8 to 12 acres around a wide common (today's Main Street area) on the plain north of Hook Pond, dividing surrounding farmland into the Eastern Plain (Egypt Lane to Cross Highway), Great Plain (Hook Pond to Lily Pond), and Little Plain (Lily Pond to Georgica Pond), with Hook Mill, Gardiner Windmill, and the Home Sweet Home house (restored under Historic District Consultant Robert J. Hefner) still standing; the late-1800s artist-colony boom that produced modest shingled cottages near Ocean Avenue and Lily Pond Lane on the Great Plain and sizable estates on the Eastern Plain by the early 1900s; Amagansett's settlement in 1680 by families including the Bakers, Conklins, and Barneses along with Dutch brothers Abraham and Jacob Schellinger (arrived 1680-1690), and a name derived from a Montaukett-language phrase meaning "place of good water"; the late-19th-century establishment of the Devon Colony by Procter & Gamble executives as an enclave built around generational, understated wealth, with properties that reportedly rarely enter the public market and maintain price discretion; Town of East Hampton population figures of 21,457 (2010 census), 28,385 (2020 census), and a July 2025 estimate of 29,400 (up 3.7% from April 2020), with a 2020 town-wide population density of 381.9 people per square mile; East Hampton Village-specific third-party estimates of a 2024 population of 1,297 and a 2026 projected population of 1,553, a reported 49.3% population change from 2019 to 2024 (a 9.9% annual rate of change), a 2024 estimated median household income of $106,250, a 3.4% family poverty rate, a median age of 57.5 years, and a race/ethnicity breakdown of 68.5% White, 25.8% Hispanic, and 2.6% two or more races -- all explicitly flagged in the source research as third-party estimates rather than confirmed U.S. Census Bureau figures at the village level for these specific years. No official Census Bureau hamlet-level population figure for Amagansett specifically was found in this research; only Town of East Hampton Census-confirmed figures and the third-party East Hampton Village estimate above are used. No specific current Devon Colony property count, price, or named family beyond "Procter & Gamble executives" was confirmed, and none is invented here. No exact current (2026) home-price, property-tax-rate, or flood-insurance figure specific to East Hampton Village or Amagansett was found; confirm current numbers with a local real estate agent, Town of East Hampton records, and a licensed insurance agent before making any purchase decision. Nothing on this page is legal, tax, or financial advice.